Detailed Outline

About the 4DEE FrameworkDownload Summary Paper [docx]

Detailed 4DEE Framework – outline

Updated July 2018

In this section we provide a more detailed version of the 4DEE framework, with the sub-elements shown.  A brief narrative describing and explaining each dimension is also given.

A. Core Ecology Concepts

The list below covers an array of concepts critical to understanding ecology. It is based, in large part, on material presented in introductory ecology textbooks and thus, represents an inventory of core ecology concepts recognized a large number of authors (historical and current; see for instance almost every edition of Begon et al., Krebs, Molles, Odum, Ricklefs, Smith & Smith, etc).  These concepts are used by many of us to construct our syllabi, to test student learning, and to shape our degree programs. This list of concepts is divided into seven groups: individuals, populations, communities, ecosystems, landscapes, biomes, and biosphere. Within each group is a set of related concepts, e.g. trophic levels, predation, food chain/web, energy flow, nutrient cycling, regulators.

  1. Autecology
    1. Abiotic and biotic features of environment
    2. Resources and regulators
    3. Habitat and niche: fundamental – realized
  2. Population
    1. Population dispersion
    2. Exponential and logistic growth – cycles
    3. Demography – life history
  3. Community
    1. Habitat types: terrestrial – marine – aquatic – wetlands – soils
    2. Species diversity – biodiversity – dominance
    3. Competition – exploitation – interference – predation – mutualism
    4. Stability – resistance – resilience – disturbance – steady state – fluctuate
    5. Succession
    6. Behavioral ecology
  4. Ecosystems
    1. Trophic levels: Producers – consumers – decomposers
    2. Predation: predator – prey – herbivore – carnivores
    3. Food chain – food web – networks – grazing – detritus
    4. Energy flow – productivity
    5. Nutrient cycling – nutrients
    6. Regulators – control from below/above – trophic cascades
  5. Landscapes
    1. Patches – corridors – barriers
    2. Gradients
    3. Watersheds
  6. Biomes
    1. Biome types: tundra, boreal forest, deciduous forest, grassland, shrubland, desert, tropical rainforest
    2. Ecological consequences of latitude and elevation
  7. Biosphere
    1. Biogeography at global level
    2. Global climate change

B. Ecology Practices

This list of practices elucidates the basic components associated with the scientific process, e.g. making observations, collecting data, and generating and testing hypotheses (Moore 1993).   It represents an essential description of approaches and skills used in and necessary for doing science, with particular attention to how ecological science is conducted. Clearly, many of these practices reflect general approaches used in most scientific disciplines (ref Brewer and Smith 2011, Table 2.1; NRC 2013) with some components unique to ecology.

  1. Natural history
    1. As an approach
    2. Making observations and connections
  2. Fieldwork
    1. Habitat assessment
    2. Field identification and preservation (of at least one large taxon)
    3. Spatial analysis (GIS, remote sensing)
  3. Quantitative reasoning and computational thinking
    1. Statistics
    2. Data skills: inputting and data-mining / meta-analysis/ data visualization
    3. Computer skills: spreadsheets, “R”
    4. Modeling and simulation
    5. Informatics
  4. Designing and critiquing investigations
    1. Study design, familiarity with basic modes of ecological inquiry (description, comparison, experimentation, modeling)
    2. Evaluating claims
    3. Argument from evidence
  5. Working collaboratively
  6. Communicating and applying ecology

C. Human-Environment Interactions 

All of us acknowledge that every place on earth is impacted to some degree by humans (see Commoner 1971). The connections between humans and the environment were a unifying theme of ESA’s Sustainable Biosphere report (Lubchenco et al. 1991).  In 2000, Crutzen and Stoermer suggested that the human effect on the environment was sufficiently significant as to constitute a new geological epoch, the Anthropocene. Recognizing this, Palmer et al. (2005) noted a “need to refocus the discipline towards research that ensures a future in which natural systems and the humans they include coexist…”and further, that “…ecologists must play a greatly expanded role in communicating their research and influencing policy and decisions that affect the environment.” Over 1000 ESA members responded to the 2007 Vice Presidents’ Survey on Ecological Literacy, and nearly half of the essential elements of ecological literacy mentioned were related to human/environment interactions (McBride 2011). More recently, Lubchenco (2017) pointed to the need for greater engagement by scientists in addressing societal problems, e.g. “We must engage more vigorously with society to address the intertwined environmental and social problems that many have ignored, to find solutions, and to help create a better world.”  To that end, educational efforts must ensure that ecology students- and even the discipline itself – attends to the interaction between humans and the environment.

The ideas listed here emphasize that bi-directional interrelationship between humans and the Earth’s biota and physical environment, with particular attention to the normative values underlying decision-making and policy (Collins et al. 2011, Jablonski, et al. 2015).  Incorporating the human-environment interactions into the 4DEE framework recognizes that every place is shaped by humans and every human need is shaped by the environment. In order to address and solve today’s problems, this understanding is necessary–and critical.

  1. Human dependence on the environment
    1. Ecosystem services (Daily 1997)
  2. Human accelerated environmental change – there is no pristine ecosystem nor total equilibrium
    1. Anthropogenic impacts, intentional and unintentional
    2. Global climate change
    3. Environmental toxicology: biomagnification – bioconcentration
  3. How humans shape and manage resources/ecosystems/the environment
    1. Urban ecosystems, urban ecology, urban-rural gradient
    2. Agricultural ecosystems, agroecology, fisheries, forestry
    3. Ecological engineering – biomimicry, ecology of gene drive systems
    4. Natural resource management
    5. Conservation biology
    6. Ecological stewardship
  4. Ethical dimensions – critical thinking about the values underlying how we approach and address environmental problems, challenges and opportunities in environmental decision-making and policy
    1. Environmental ethics – basic types of ethics and their sources/foundations (includes ecological
    2. Sustainability as a normative, socially constructed, aspirational goal
    3. Environmental justice
    4. Ecological economics (Daly and Cobb 1990)

 

D. Cross-Cutting Themes

Many ecologically-related ideas and approaches do not fall neatly along the other three dimensions – interactions, practices, and especially the hierarchy of core concepts.  Some interrelate to other areas of science, while others, although ecologically related, place different demands in how they are studied. Vision and Change in Undergraduate Biology Education (Brewer and Smith 2011) recommended that “all undergraduates need to understand” evolution, pathways and transformations of energy and matter, information flow, exchange, and storage, structure and function, and systems.  Here, we focus on four elements that are often thought of as approaches or ways of thinking: pathways and transformations of matter and energy, structure and function, systems, and spatial and temporal. Because evolution is itself change over space and time, it has been placed within spatial and temporal. 

  1. Structure & Function
  2. Pathways & Transformations of Matter and energy
  3. Systems
  4. Spatial & Temporal
    1. Scales
    2. Stability & change
    3. Evolution
      1. Mutation
      2. Microevolution
      3. Macroevolution
    4.  Biogeography
      1. Range – cosmopolitan / endemic
      2. Native / alien / invasives