Field Talk: Local spearfishing stories tell of fish depletion in Chile

Historically, spearfishing involved a diver, a harpoon (or spear or trident) and access to an abundant source of fish. However, it has evolved over the centuries—especially within the last few decades—to include boats, masks, snorkeling gear, scuba tanks, wet suits and even spearguns. The modernization of equipment means divers are able to stay underwater for hours and fire mechanically propelled spears at faster rates than a person is able to throw. The result, in theory, is a more fruitful catch.

However, Natalio Godoy from the Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile and colleagues found that the spearfishers’ catches are becoming less diverse and abundant in the temperate reefs in northern and central Chile. The result, as they suggest in a recent study published in Ecological Applications, is likely due in part to the spearfishing activities themselves.

Godoy and colleagues used several methods to obtain information on the state of reef fish communities in Chile since records of spearfishing activities, and landing records specific to certain regions, are not required by the government. Therefore, the researchers examined data from nation-wide official landing records, the catch from the top 20 divers in the 1971 and 2004 world spearfishing championships and the perceptions of local spearfishers.

They found that the average mass of reef fish captured decreased, the percentage of discarded fish decreased and the total number of species caught decreased drastically in the 30 year span between championships. The interviews, on the other hand, contributed an even greater understanding
of the status of the fisheries: Divers reported that they were catching, and local markets were accepting, species of fish that were not consumed just 10-15 years ago. Raul Choque—Chilean snorkeling speargun world champion in 1971—described this shift in the study: “Before 1985, the main target species were large carnivore rocky fish [like Graus nigra or Semicossyphus darwini]; however today, we catch anything, even Jerguilla [herbivorous reef fish], which no one used to eat 10 years ago because of its bad taste.”

Choque’s quote is evidence of both the lack of management and the decline in catch diversity seen in Chile in the last couple of decades. As Stefan Gelcich, one of the co-authors, explained in a Field Talk podcast interview, “There is less catch available, so the whole market has shifted in a way. These local market [are selling] herbivore species [now],” he said. “And this has changed in not that long [of a] time. When we were speargun diving at university with [Godoy], no one used to eat Jerguilla, and that was only…10 or 15 years ago. So this change has been quite fast in terms of composition of the catch.”

The authors recommend, both in the paper and in the interview, several policy changes that they believe need to occur soon to reestablish the fisheries. Godoy outlined the specifics:

“One of the major limitations on regulating spearfishing is that the official fishery data are rather poor. Evidence suggests that in these cases the development of fishery management policy options requires the combination of multiple sources of information in order to understand the historical status and dynamics of fisheries. Our study shows that unregulated spearfishing has depleted reef fishes in temperate near-shore ecosystems along part of the Chilean coast and has also caused shifts in the composition of catches over time, thus signaling a spearfishing reef fish crisis.

Hopefully [this is] a prerequisite for initiating policy discussions aimed at the sustainable management of fisheries. These policies would include strong regulations on hookah diving [diving with compressed air from a boat], reproductive period bans and size regulations. Additionally, the use of [territorial use rights in fisheries] (TURFs) provides a fundamental building block to begin developing these initiatives.”

The authors said in the interview that the researchers are not recommending a complete ban on spearfishing activities all together. Their goal is to regulate the activities so there is a more stable population for local fishers to use as sustenance. Co-author Juan Carlos Castilla explained:

“You have to remember that in many cases this activity is done on a sustainable basis for the people who live in this area. So, it’s not for the big markets around the world—it’s not for Japan or Washington or New York, whatever—it’s local subsistence for the fishers.”

Author: Katie Kline

Moderator of EcoTone and ESA's communications officer.

Share This Post On

3 Comments

  1. I wonder if 2 samples taken 30 years apart, from disparate locations, can tell you much except that reef fisheries, along with many other fisheries, has declined over that period. During the same period rainfall has shifted, the climate has changed, and the total number of fishermen has increased. Since the government statistics doesn’t break out spearfishing from other methods, all that tells us is that, in general, all fisheries takes have decreased. Most spear fishing catches are landed and marketed locally. The government never sees them. Fishery Management Commissions have indicated that reef fishing is most affected by habitat destruction, pollution, and unregulated artesianal fishing; particularly trap fishing.

  2. Spearfishing is an eco friendly way to catch fish if practice with a conscience. You can see your catch, for one and decide if the fish is a proper size. Also spearfishing with tanks isn’t spearfishing. It is murder and should be outlawed in all countries. If you spearfish with a tank, you should loose your equipment. Another thing, commercial fishermen take more than 90 percent if not higher of all fish caught. So don’t blame spearfishing for fish depletion. Give me a break.

  3. Really? Spearfishing is the cause of the decline? The least efficient method of fishing besides rod and reel, the absolute least popular method of harvesting fish–this is the reason fish stocks are being depleted. What about longline fishing? What about the massive Chinese and other Asian fleets illegally fishing in our waters? No, couldn’t possibly be any of those things. It’s the guys and girls in wetsuits with *gasp* rubber band-powered GUNS!

    Who writes this stuff, and how much did the Chinese government pay you?

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>